Lawsuit filed to Challenge Calico Complex Gather

President Barack Obama and Vice President Joe Biden
Phone: 202-456-1111 or 202-456-9000
Fax: 202-456-2461
On behalf of members of Animal Law Coalition, I appreciate the opportunity to provide you with comments on the planned removal of 2,476-2,523 wild horses from the Nevada Calico Mountain Complex that is scheduled to begin December 1. A number of ALC members enjoy the wild horses and burros and are very concerned that they are fast disappearing from the wild pursuant to what appears to be a concerted effort to eliminate them from their historic ranges and herd areas.Black Rock Range East
Black Rock Range West
Calico Mountains
Granite Range
Warm Springs Canyon
"It would be anomalous to infer that by authorizing the custodian of the wild free roaming horses and burros to ‘manage' them, Congress intended to permit the animals' custodian to subvert the primary policy of the statute by capturing and removing from the wild the very animals that Congress sought to protect from being captured and removed from the wild.Defendants argue that the horses will not be ‘eradicated' or ‘eliminated' inasmuch as BLM intends to continue to manage the horses not in the wild but through private adoption or long-term care. ...But BLM's directive is ‘to protect and manage wild free-roaming horses and burros as components of the public lands . . . .' 16 U.S.C. § 1333(a) (emphasis added). Congress did not authorize BLM to ‘manage' the wild horses by corralling them for private maintenance or long-term care as non-wild free-roaming animals off of the public lands.Upon removal for private adoption and/or long-term care, the ... Herd would forever cease to be ‘wild free-roaming' horses ‘as components of the public lands' contrary to Congress's intent to protect the horses from capture.Moreover, the statute expressly provides that BLM's ‘management activities shall be at the minimal feasible level . . . .' It is difficult to think of a ‘management activity' that is farther from a ‘minimal feasible level' than removal."
At the least, there has to be a better way to manage these animals other than by hiring criminals to run them down with helicopters and penning some for life and sending others to slaughter.
Also, surely, BLM cannot seriously suggest it has taken a "hard look" at different alternatives. The alternatives BLM proposed are simply (1) removing thousands of horses and sterilizing many of those remaining, (2) removing thousands of wild horses, or (3) doing nothing now, a "no action" alternative NEPA requires BLM to include. Laura Allen
Executive Director
Animal Law Coalition
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| CalicocomplexgatherEAinput11102009.doc | 48.5 KB |
| NV_Calico Complex_PC-1_11-09-09.pdf | 167.31 KB |









"As a veterinarian, I believe that it is my responsibility to treat all of my patients in a humane manner. Looking at the condition of slaughter-bound horses in the videos and photographs taken by journalists, investigators and welfare personnel (over many years), I could never explain to a client or to a child what is humane about their transport, and I would certainly never recommend this avenue of disposing of a horse to a client."
"When I was a young girl I was lucky enough to share my life with horses and ponies and these wonderful creatures of grace and loyalty taught me more about compassion than I ever learnt in school. I have written songs to raise awareness of what is happening to America's horses and I support wholeheartedly the tremendously dedicated efforts of equine advocates, members of the public and indeed the producers and crew of Saving America's Horses, without whom it would be hard to envisage an end to the abhorrent slaughter of our most noble and forgiving friends."
"The duplicity of some horse people and of some horse organizations is appalling. They expect good treatment of the horse until it is convenient to dispose of them at which time they are OK with the horribly inhumane treatment of the horse in the horse slaughter system (from sale yard, hauling, feed lots to the slaughter plant)." 
















“If any vegans came over for dinner, I could whip them up a salad, then explain my philosophy on being a carnivore: If God had not intended for us to eat animals, how come He made them out of meat?”
The open letter was
Stop the roundups - all of them.
My first comment regarding the Calico Mountain Complex roundup is there is an over abundance of cattle is this area not wild horses. There was a 300% increase for cattle grazing last year along with a fence building project which cut the horses off from water and grazing areas because wild horse numbers were minimal. Then, bingo, your numbers suddenly reflect an abundant population and now you want to round up what's left.
All of them.
Respectfully,
Gail Fox