Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
corydorasandmore · Corydoras and More - For Catfish Of All Kinds-Tropical to Natives
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Real people. Real stories. See how Yahoo! Groups impacts members worldwide.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Driftwood Expiration ?   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #3427 of 3459 |
Re: [Corydoras and More] Driftwood Expiration ?

I have never had to worry about pH that low, so I'm not sure what kits are available.  Sorry. I'm sure that if there are not cheap ones for home use, like test strips or color titrate kits, that there are meters that should cover it, but that might get a bit more expensive.  I do know people that live in Long Island that have to filter their water through crush coral and sea shells etc in order to raise the pH enough so they can keep fish. Really low pH is about as bad as high pH, but is easier to deal with. High pH goes along with really hard water, and there is no good cheap way to lower the pH without time consuming effort like you have experienced, or expensive systems like RO and ion exchange. You can pour acid into an aquarium and drop the pH insanely low, and in a day or so, it is right back up where it was, since the minerals and other bad things are still there and buffer the water. Stable pH is much more important than perfect levels as pH for keeping fish. They may not like it, and may not thrive, and may not breed, but they can live in water that is outside their comfort range. Neon tetras much prefer and come from pH of 6 or around there. They do okay in Indpls water, which is basically liquid rock, as it comes from the tap at 8.6 or so. African cichlids thrive in it, with no special treatments like cichlid or rift lake salts (mineral compounds not just salt). People that use RO systems know that about 80% or more of the water they run through a system, is passed off as waste water through the baffles. They keep this for Africans, and use the RO for their special fish that like the  S/Am beauties. If you want a fish that might do well in that small tank, you could try a betta. Three gallons would seem like a swimming pool to him.



--- On Fri, 7/17/09, hwuya <no_reply@yahoogroups.com> wrote:

From: hwuya <no_reply@yahoogroups.com>
Subject: Re: [Corydoras and More] Driftwood Expiration ?
To: corydorasandmore@yahoogroups.com
Date: Friday, July 17, 2009, 1:39 AM

 
Les,

As usual, thanks for the thoughtful response. I guess the one big question I have is can wood bring the PH too low ? And are there kits to measure PH below 6 ?

Thanks again !

Hans

--- In corydorasandmore@ yahoogroups. com, Les Mumford <lesmumford@ ...> wrote:
>
> Ahhhhhh, you have discovered one of the hidden benefitsd to using real wood in an aquarium. As it sits in the water, the natural tannins contained in the wood slowly leech out into the surrounding waters. Larger aquariums don't show the discoloration as quickly as smaller ones, due to the dilution factor. These tannins do slowly lower the pH of the surrounding water. The longer it is there, the lower it goes, basically, and doing small changes in a small tank allow the tannins to build up, where they would be removed quicker in a larger tank with corresponding larger water changesFish from the Amazon, or some other large water systems in rainforest areas would appreciate this type of water a lot. Neon tetras would thrive and breed readily in it, if they were not captive bred types that have slowly adjusted to higher pH levels. Abrupt changes to the lower pH ranges can be devastating to fish, even if they are from naturally low pH ranges. If you do decide
> to add fish, you will not be able to add a lot anyway, due to it only being a three gallon tank, but slowly accustom them to the water, just as you would adding them to a higher pH level tank. Or, adding new fish to an existing set up. Good activated carbon will help remove the tannis, and clear the water color if that bothers you. The tannins discoloration is just a basic warning to you of the water conditions. Many people store water in large plastic cans with wood to naturally lower the pH so they can do their water changes into similar set ups without disrupting the pH ranges they have worked so hard to get. Many killies, and wild caught imported fish, and even a lot of the captive bred fish you can get in shops will only breed in the low pH ranges, and this is one way of getting it without using a lot of chemicals that really don't work well, or from using expensive systems like RO units and ion exchange units. They may adapt to living in the
> higher pH ranges, but they will not thrive, and will not breed, and even if some of them do breed, the spawns will be very small, or the fry may not survive. With some fish like discus, it has been proven that harder water and higher pH ranges cause the egg skin to harden prematurly and before the male's sperm can fertilize the eggs, soo it looks like a good spawning, but the eggs just fungus over since they were not viable.
>  
> Fish like actually eat the driftwood, like some of the bristlenose plecs, and fish that grave on the wood for the small animals they eat from the surface of the wood, like the very small
> plecs, will help keep the wood in better looking condition, but all wood placed in water will eventually rot and fall apart, and will need to be replaced. (except maybe something like ironwood from exotic places). Different woods used will make a difference also. Oak and some others are better for the aquarium, as things like pine has that natural pitch which doesn't do well in water. A friend of mine used to use applewood from his back yard, as he knew it was not contaminated with pesticides etc.  If you pick up wood, it needs to be treated to make sure it does not contain parasites, or other bad things, and the bark removed if present, as it will disintegrate and foul the water quickly.  Most wood will also float until it is saturated. So if you fetch your own, peel the bark, and soak it in a plastic trash can or similar, and use a med to kill parasites etc before using it in an aquarium.
>  
> I hope I got it all in here. If I missed a point, or you have other questions, ask away. 
>




Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:56 pm

lesmumford
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #3427 of 3459 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Hi Les, I have been a lurker on this group for a while now and am always impressed with the patience and advice you give. I was wondering if you might be able...
hwuya
Offline
Jul 13, 2009
10:54 pm

Ahhhhhh, you have discovered one of the hidden benefitsd to using real wood in an aquarium. As it sits in the water, the natural tannins contained in the wood...
Les Mumford
lesmumford
Offline Send Email
Jul 14, 2009
8:12 pm

Les, As usual, thanks for the thoughtful response. I guess the one big question I have is can wood bring the PH too low ? And are there kits to measure PH...
hwuya
Offline
Jul 17, 2009
5:39 am

I have never had to worry about pH that low, so I'm not sure what kits are available.  Sorry. I'm sure that if there are not cheap ones for home use, like...
Les Mumford
lesmumford
Offline Send Email
Jul 17, 2009
6:56 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help